Forums

JOIGNEZ-VOUS À LA COMMUNAUTÉ
INSCRIVEZ-VOUSIdentifiant

How many Superchargers will there be in Europe? And will ALL the European countries get Superchargers? Eastern Europe as well?

As many as in the United states?

At least 150 Superchargers in Europe? But I would prefer even more.

It wouldn't be nice if a certain part of Europe is left out.

I think that they will start placing them in the Western part of Europe, and as the time goes by they will step by step go to the Eastern part of Europe.

Depends on permissions and available sites. Might be the reverse.

Having recently completed a motorcycle tour of Eastern Europe, I have doubts there would be much demand for Teslas there, just as there are almost no luxury car dealers there except in the major cities. Most of the vehicles we saw there were very old, many Soviet-era, interspersed with ox carts and inexpensive newer Korean and Spanish autos. Didn't see a single Porsche, Ferrari, or even high end Benz. Declining population does not make a good argument for investment. It was a great trip, but unimaginable place to live. The Czech Republic was better than Poland, which was better than Hungary, which was better than Slovakia, but everywhere people are looking for ways to get out. Formerly great societies and interesting cultures, but not much geographic interest compared to Western EU.

And there won't be hundreds in Europe. The wildest plan for the US is dozens, not hundreds. The whole west coast is covered end to end by only eight or nine chargers. Tesla's stated goal is to cover all US intercity travel requirements with fewer than 100 Superchargers. Remember that these are intended not for regular use in urban areas, rather primarily for long distance travel.

I would expect Europe to have proportionately fewer than we need in the US because it is more compact and dense. People will be able to charge at home and make it easily to another city where they can charge on the government-provided units. Socialism will trump the capitalist model and Tesla won't need to spend the money on a zero-return network. Hard to compete with "free".

Europe as area is just as big as US. We need approximately same amount of chargers. Also I don't think Norwegian people would like to go to Sweden to charge, so possibly more because countries are countries, not states.

P_D;
TM's US map showed 100 by the end of 2013, and 193 by the end of 2015 or so.

Timo;
Not hardly. "The area of the United States (including Alaska and Hawaii) is 9,161,923 km2, while the area of Europe is 3,788,027 km2. The United States is almost two and a half times the size of the European Union." And 40% of Europe's area is in Russia. So the comparison is really about 9 vs 2.2 million square km. About 4:1!

Here's a fun map: http://goeurope.about.com/od/europeanmaps/l/bl-country-size-comparison-m...

Europe is over 10 million km^2. I don't know which part of the Europe is that 3.7 million, but that definitely is not the whole Europe. Even if we would not count the area in Russia it would still add up over 6 million km^2.

Brian - Tesla promised 13 SC in CA by YE 2013 and 86 SC in US within 2 years (YE2014). In my book Tesla is ahead of schedule. But about 100 SCito cover the US is probably what is needed...
In Europe you need only 3 SC to got from the North Sea to the Swiss Alps... 150 seem way excessive compared to 100 in the US.
However in Europe the conditions are completely different. In the US many people have a garage with resonable power outlet (dryer). In Europe only few have a garage, most people park on the street. Running a charging cable over the walkway at night is not a good solution. The current Tesla solution "charge your car at night in your garage" is perfect for the US but will not work in Europe. It will be interesting how Tesla will address the situation in Europe in the coming years.

Yes, overnight charging is going to be tough to arrange for most! Maybe a new business: Tesla garages, where you park and charge every night for a monthly fee?

Kleist;

"In Europe you need only 3 SC to got from the North Sea to the Swiss Alps"

And another three to get from Hanko to Utsjoki within Finland. Sweden and Norway are longer.

Conditions in Europe are different than in US for road trips. Some small country like Netherlands you could cover with one or not at all if you put it in nearby country, but there's the problem, it would be in nearby *country*. Not state.

Tesla Motors has decided to have its Distribution Center in Tilburg, The Nethelands. That means that all the Tesla EV's that are manufactured for the European market and are coming from the Tesla Motors factory in Fremont will first go to Tilburg, The Netherlands. That's pretty important, I would think. And the first Supercharger will be put nearby this Tesla Motors Distribution Center in Tilburg, The Netherlands. That makes sense to me.

By the way, I think there will be in total 4 Superchargers in The Netherlands.

Four? Why? Longest possible route I can get with Google maps in Netherlands is about 400km. One is sufficient to that, two would be plenty, four is overkill.

If the SC density is 4 in that small area, then 150 total is severe underestimation. Extrapolating from that I get about 700 of them for 6 million km^2.

Brian, I don't see tat many on the map, but Tesla excs have stated numerous times that 100 will cover the entire US long distance travel requirement.

Benz, where TM puts service sales and import locations bears no relation to Supercharger locations. The first two SC locations in the eastern US are many miles away from any TM facility. That's by design. TM facilities go where population is concentrated. Superchargers go specifically where population is NOT concentrated, so that people can make it from one population center to the next, and then plug into the regular chargers that are already at many commercial locations, home, and work.

Timo, Europe is definitely 3.9 million square miles (10.1 sq km) and much smaller than North America's land area. That includes all of Russia. And travel there works just like in the US. I have driven and motorcycled in and between every EU country and have never encountered a barrier (since about 1999).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europe

P_D;
They said a hundred would be minimally adequate, but I counted. The full map had 193.

P_D; 10.1 Mkm^2 is larger than US which is 9Mkm^2. Brian H or I didn't say "North America". That's a lot bigger than US.

EU might not be permanent, and not all countries in Europe are members of EU. Countries are countries there, not states, and rules between borders might change.

@Timo; however, you already know that SCs are meant for long distance travel, placed strategically on the major routes. Not for everyday use. I.e. a person from the Netherlands would typically charge at home, but would charge in Belgium on their trip to France...

Yes, SCs should be linked to data bases, and refuse to charge MSes owned by anyone living closer than 150 km. ;) ;p

Benz mentioned that there will be four SC in Netherlands. That's a lot for that small area.

I don't know what TM thinks is the best placements for SC:s in Europe, but it is different place than US. Languages change, cultures change and rules change between borders, not everybody understands everyone else. I think you might want to put at least one in every small country (miniature countries not counted).

Tesla Motors know where their customers are located. This information will be used when Tesla Motors will decide where the Superchargers are going to be located.

Luxemborg will get 12 because they are rich and Poland will get none because all the poles with money already live in London...

Seriously 3 would cover NL ok.

If I was in the government of Andorra, Lichenstein or San Marino I would seriously push to get a supercharger site as it would bring in high end visitors...

@Kleist " In Europe only few have a garage, most people park on the street. Running a charging cable over the walkway at night is not a good solution. "
You are absolutely right about most people, however people who buy a €80.000 car are not "most people". I'm pretty sure most of them have a garage. For the Gen3 car this however is going to be a serious issue in Europe.

@P_D; "I have driven and motorcycled in and between every EU country and have never encountered a barrier (since about 1999)."
Very true as far as fysical barriers are concerned but crossing into another county just to get juiced up is something only people who live really close to a border are used to. Would people who live in the south of California be cool about crossing into Mexico to juice up if that country is not your actual destination? I don't know.

@ArieK - you are right it doesn't apply to current MS buyers. In the US the charge at home model at night and travel long distance via SC is very extenable well beyond Gen3. Question was what is a practical model/ concept in Europe? And the question is EV in general in Europe not limited to Tesla.. I can think of only two convenient places to charge daily: home and work.

Commercial neighbourhood charging garages? Pay for a spot and electricity, as often as needed.

@ Brian H

"Commercial neighbourhood charging garages? Pay for a spot and electricity, as often as needed."

And have solar panels on the roof of these garages. And a "massive battery" in these garages that can store lots of electricity. And charge the EV with the electricity that has been stored in this "massive battery", so that charging at night is possible as well. That would be a good idea, I think.

Has such a "massive battery" already been developed and manufactured? Can it already be bought on the market?

Batteries can be stacked as high as you want.

Benz - e.g. MS battery assembly - 6 feet high are 18 stacked packs times 60kWh ( e.g. used 85kWh packs ) gives you about 1GWh in the space that a single car occupies.

You mean 1MWh. k(ilo)-M(ega)-G(iga).

Yes that was supposed be MWh... Nice catch.


X Deutschland Site Besuchen